• Go to app
  • Select a destination
  • 11 Broadway Shows That Turn First-Timers Into Fans

    Chariza Leen Crudo
    Chariza Leen Crudo
    Last updated 12 Sep 2025
    more
    Collage of popular Broadway musicals perfect for first-time theatergoers

    Top Broadway shows first-timers should experience in New York City

    Lights, Magic, Broadway! ✨

    A trip to New York is incomplete without Broadway. A home to the stars and pop culture, the avenue has cemented itself as a must-see destination in the US. From larger-than-life musical numbers to jaw-dropping set designs, the best Broadway shows promise unforgettable moments that stay with you long after the curtain falls.
    But with so many shows lighting up the streets of NYC, how do you choose the right one? Whether you want to sing along to Disney classics, laugh till your stomach hurts, or get lost in a heartfelt story, we’ve got you covered. So, check off each show on this list of 11 Broadway shows you must catch on your next (or first) trip to the Big Apple!

    What is Broadway?

    The name alone conjures up a hub of culture, talent, and art. Paradise for theater enthusiasts, Broadway is a 13-mile street stretching across Manhattan and the Bronx. Its iconic status didn't happen overnight—it's a legacy spanning two and a half centuries. In fact, the first musical, The Black Crook, debuted on Broadway in 1866, and the rest is history. 

    1. Moulin Rouge! The Musical 💃

    Fall in love with the star of Moulin Rouge, Satine!
    Fall in love with the star of Moulin Rouge, Satine!
    The masterpiece features the young poet Christian, who falls in love with Satine, the star of the Moulin Rouge and a cabaret performer. With dazzling choreography, jaw-dropping costumes, and hit songs from your favorite pop stars like Katy Perry, this musical is a thrilling journey through passion, romance, and over-the-top showbiz glamour. It’s an all-out spectacle that grabs your attention from start to finish.
    📍 Venue: Al Hirschfeld Theatre, 302 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036

    2. The Lion King 🦁

    Hakuna Matata your way to New York!
    Hakuna Matata your way to New York!
    The Lion King is a timeless classic that transcends age, captivating audiences young and old alike. With hits like Hakuna Matata and Circle of Life, watch the African savannah come to life and get swept up in the magic!
    📍 Venue: Minskoff Theatre, 200 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036

    3. Chicago 🎷

    Be transported to Chicago in the Big Apple!
    Be transported to Chicago in the Big Apple!
    Set in the jazz-fueled 1920s, Chicago brings glitz, sass, and killer dance numbers to the stage. The longest-running musical on Broadway follows Roxie, an aspiring jazz singer who manipulates the public and the courts in 1920s America. With timeless hits like “All That Jazz” and “Cell Block Tango,” this show has everything: drama, humor, and award-winning choreography.
    📍 Venue: Ambassador Theatre, 219 W 49th St, New York, NY 10019

    4. Wicked 🧙‍♀️

    Defy gravity with Galinda and Elphaba!
    Defy gravity with Galinda and Elphaba!
    With Wicked: Part One having captivated moviegoers last year and Part Two on the horizon, the buzz around this iconic story is stronger than ever. Still, nothing beats experiencing the magic where it all began; live on Broadway! Featuring powerful numbers like “Defying Gravity” and “Popular,” the musical follows Elphaba’s unforgettable transformation from curious student to the legendary Wicked Witch of the West.
    📍 Venue: Gershwin Theatre, 222 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019

    5. Aladdin 🧞‍♂️

    Aladdin will take you wonder by wonder one song at a time!
    Aladdin will take you wonder by wonder one song at a time!
    Step into a whole new world with Aladdin and Jasmine as they soar through a magical love story packed with colorful sets, catchy tunes, and a hilarious Genie. This is Broadway fun at its most enchanting—and ideal for families.
    📍 Venue: New Amsterdam Theatre, 214 W 42nd St, New York, NY 10036

    6. Six the Musical 👑

    Join the royal revolution of Six!
    Join the royal revolution of Six!
    The six wives of Henry VIII take center stage in this girl-power-packed pop concert. Each queen tells her story through catchy songs and fierce choreography. If you love modern beats and cheeky lyrics, Six is the royal treatment you need.
    📍 Venue: Lena Horne Theatre, 256 W 47th St, New York, NY 10036

    7. The Book of Mormon

    Follow the journey of Elder Price and Cunningham!
    Follow the journey of Elder Price and Cunningham!
    From the creators of South Park, this irreverent musical is outrageously funny, super catchy, and surprisingly heartfelt. It’s one of those shows that makes you laugh, cringe, and clap all at once. Definitely a top pick for grown-up first-timers!
    📍 Venue: Eugene O'Neill Theatre, 230 W 49th St, New York, NY 10019

    8. & Juliet: The New Musical  💘

    Catch this modern take on the classic tale now!
    Catch this modern take on the classic tale now!
    What if Juliet didn’t die at the end of Romeo & Juliet? & Juliet flips the script on Shakespeare’s classic tragedy and turns it into a pop-powered celebration of second chances and self-discovery. Set to the music of Max Martin (think Britney Spears, Katy Perry, and Backstreet Boys), this high-energy musical is all about rewriting your own story—literally and figuratively.
    It’s witty, empowering, and packed with songs you already know and love. If you're a fan of feel-good vibes, strong female leads, and dance-in-your-seat music, & Juliet is a must for your first Broadway outing.
    📍 Venue: Stephen Sondheim Theatre, 124 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036

    9. Maybe Happy Ending 🤖

    Maybe Happy Ending musical featuring two characters with luggage on stage
    Two robot characters meet in the heartwarming musical Maybe Happy Ending
    This futuristic love story between two robots is surprisingly emotional and deeply human. With clever staging and a fresh narrative, Maybe Happy Ending is perfect if you’re looking for something thoughtful and a little off the beaten path.
    📍 Venue: MCC Theater, 511 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019

    10. The Great Gatsby 🎉

    Cast of The Great Gatsby musical dancing in a dazzling 1920s party scene
    Jay Gatsby and Daisy in a glamorous party scene from The Great Gatsby musical
    Step into the dazzling world of 1920s New York as Jay Gatsby throws his infamous parties in this stylish, high-energy production. Expect stunning visuals, a swinging soundtrack, and plenty of drama, all dripping in Art Deco flair.
    📍 Venue: Broadway Theatre, 1681 Broadway, New York, NY 10019

    11. Death Becomes Her 💄

    Broadway cast performing Death Becomes Her on a grand staircase set
    A scene from Death Becomes Her with dramatic staging and diva performances
    If you’re in the mood for something outrageously fun, fabulously over-the-top, and packed with diva energy—Death Becomes Her is it. Adapted from the cult-classic film, this new Broadway musical is deliciously campy, hysterically funny, and full of jaw-dropping performances.
    With larger-than-life characters, snappy dialogue, and glam costumes that could kill (literally), the show is a wild ride from start to finish. First-timers looking for something bold and unforgettable? You’ve found it.
    📍 Venue: Lunt-Fontanne Theatre, 205 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

    FAQs About Broadway Shows 🎟️

    What is the most popular Broadway show right now?

    Hamilton, Wicked, and The Lion King continue to lead the pack. These iconic shows are almost always in high demand, so be sure to book your Broadway tickets in advance if you have your heart set on them.

    What is considered the best Broadway show?

    That really depends on what you're looking for. Critics and fans often call Hamilton a masterpiece, while Wicked and Chicago are considered Broadway staples. If you want a crowd-pleaser with stunning visuals, The Lion King is a great pick.

    What are the big 3 musicals?

    The “big 3” are generally The Lion King, Wicked, and Hamilton. These shows have huge fan bases, long runs, and critical acclaim—making them perfect for first-time Broadway-goers.

    What day is Broadway the cheapest?

    Tuesdays and Wednesdays usually have the best deals. Matinee shows are also a great way to save on ticket prices while still enjoying the full Broadway experience.

    Final Curtain Call 🎭

    Whether you want to belt out Disney classics, dive into dramatic love stories, or laugh your way through clever comedy, these Broadway shows are a perfect introduction to New York’s iconic theater scene.
    What is Klook?
    Klook is a leading pan-regional experiences platform in Asia Pacific, purpose built to digitalize experiences and make them accessible to every traveler.
    Our mission is to build the digital infrastructure for the global experience economy — empowering merchants to share their passions and travelers to discover the heartbeat of each destination. We operate a mobile-first, curated platform featuring diverse experiences across global destinations.
    ✨ Follow us for more deals and inspiration for your upcoming travels
    📸 Instagram | 📱 TikTok | ✏️ Blog | 🔴 YouTube
    more