Brooklyn isn’t just another borough in New York; it’s a pizza lover’s paradise. Walk down almost any street and you’ll find a slice shop, coal-fired oven, or family-run pizzeria locals swear by. This area is full of pizza spots, from classic pizzerias to modern slice shops, offering something for every taste.
Many come here just to eat. And honestly, it’s worth it. Brooklyn’s pizza culture combines Italian traditions, New York creativity, and neighborhood pride. One moment, you can enjoy a crispy coal-oven pie, and the next, try a modern sourdough slice.
In this guide, we’ll share nine of the best pizza shops in Brooklyn. Some are legendary institutions, while others push the boundaries of what pizza can be. Either way, they’re all worth adding to your food itinerary.
Ready to eat your way across Brooklyn? Grab a slice, and let’s begin! 🍕
If you want classic Brooklyn pizza,
1. L&B Spumoni Gardens
Sicilian slice of L&B Spumoni Gardens | Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
When locals talk about the best pizza in Brooklyn, L&B Spumoni Gardens is almost always brought up. This Gravesend institution has been serving pizza since 1938, and its famous “upside-down” Sicilian slice is unlike anything else.
Instead of putting sauce under the cheese, L&B flips the order. The cheese melts directly onto the thick dough, while the slightly sweet tomato sauce sits on top. The result is a chewy, satisfying slice that has become a Brooklyn classic.
The square slice is the star of the show, but ordering a full pie is also a great idea. After your pizza, grab a scoop of their famous spumoni ice cream to complete the experience.
Want to explore more foodie hotspots nearby? Check out this best of Brooklyn food and culture tour and taste even more local favorites!
L&B Spumoni Gardens
⭐ Rating: 4.6/5
🗒️ Price range: $5–$25
📍 Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Sicilian square slice
2. Di Fara Pizza
Classic round pizza with basil of Di Fara Pizza | Photo Credit: Flickr
Few places represent the heart of Brooklyn pizza like Di Fara. Opened in 1965, this Midwood staple built its reputation through high-quality ingredients and careful preparation.
For decades, founder Dom DeMarco personally made every pie. Even today, the pizzeria keeps his traditions alive. Each slice features rich tomato sauce, fresh basil, and a drizzle of imported olive oil.
The crust strikes a perfect balance, crispy on the outside but tender inside. It’s easy to see why so many pizza lovers consider Di Fara among the best pizza in Brooklyn. Expect a line, but the wait is part of the experience. And once you take your first bite, you’ll understand why generations of New Yorkers keep coming back.
Planning to explore more affordable eats around the city? Browse our affordable eats in NYC guide for even more food ideas!
Di Fara Pizza
⭐ Rating: 4.7/5
🗒️ Price range: $6–$30
📍 Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Classic round slice with basil
3. Totonno’s
Margherita pie of Totonno’s | Photo Credit: Flickr
Founded in 1924, Totonno’s is one of the oldest pizzerias in America. Located in Coney Island, this historic spot still bakes its pizzas in a coal-fired oven.
Did you know that coal ovens burn hotter than standard pizza ovens? It creates the perfect crispy crust with a slightly smoky flavor. That’s exactly what makes Totonno’s pies so memorable.
The menu keeps things simple: classic toppings, fresh mozzarella, and rich tomato sauce. Sometimes the simplest pizzas are the best. If you’re exploring Coney Island beach and craving authentic pizza history, this stop belongs on your list of the best pizza in Brooklyn.
Totonno’s
⭐ Rating: 4.5/5
🗒️ Price range: $20–$35
📍 Address: 1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Coal-oven Margherita pie
4. Juliana’s Pizza Brooklyn
NYC pizza cooked in a coal oven | Photo Credit: David Levinson on Pexels
Located in DUMBO, Juliana's Pizza Brooklyn is one of the borough’s most famous coal-oven pizzerias. It was founded by the legendary pizza maker Patsy Grimaldi, who returned to the neighborhood with a new restaurant after selling his original shop.
Today, Juliana’s serves beautifully blistered pizzas cooked in a coal oven. The crust comes out thin, crispy, and slightly smoky.
Many locals actually prefer Juliana’s over neighboring pizzerias because of its consistency and relaxed atmosphere. It’s a perfect stop after walking or joining a Brooklyn Bridge big group bike tour!
Juliana’s Pizza Brooklyn
⭐ Rating: 4.7/5
🗒️ Price range: $18–$30
📍 Address: 19 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Coal-oven white pizza
5. Antonio’s Pizza
Classic NYC cheese slice | Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons
For a classic neighborhood slice shop, Antonio's Pizza is a local favorite. It may not have the same fame as some historic spots, but its pizzas deliver that authentic New York slice experience.
The crust is thin, crispy, and foldable, exactly what you want from a classic slice. The sauce is rich and slightly tangy, balancing perfectly with the melted mozzarella.
They also offer vegetarian options and are known for serving one of the best gluten-free pizza options in the Brooklyn area. If you want a quick, satisfying slice without the crowds, Antonio’s is a great stop during your Brooklyn food adventure.
Antonio’s Pizza Brooklyn
⭐ Rating: 4.5/5
🗒️ Price range: $4–$20
📍 Address: 318 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Classic NY cheese slice
If you want Brooklyn pizzas with a twist
6. L’Industrie Pizzeria
Burrata pizza slice | Photo Credit: Pixnio
If you’re searching for modern pizza perfection, L’Industrie Pizzeria should be at the top of your list. Many locals say this Williamsburg favorite serves some of the best pizza in Brooklyn and even New York City.
The crust is thin yet airy, with just the right amount of char. Every slice comes out crisp, chewy, and perfectly balanced. One of the highlights is the burrata slice. Creamy burrata cheese melts beautifully over the tomato sauce, creating a rich but fresh flavor.
Lines can get long, especially on weekends. But trust us, the wait is worth it.
After grabbing a slice, explore nearby Williamsburg spots like Joe's Pizza Williamsburg, another local favorite for classic New York slices.
L’Industrie Pizzeria
⭐ Rating: 4.8/5
🗒️ Price range: $5–$28
📍 Address: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Burrata slice
7. Cuts & Slices
Oxtail pizza | Photo Credit: Food and Drink Destinations
If you’re curious about bold flavors, Cuts & Slices in Bedford-Stuyvesant is a must-visit. This popular spot became famous for its wildly creative pizzas.
Instead of traditional toppings, you’ll see options like chicken and waffles, curry shrimp, and even lasagna pizza. The real highlight, however, is the oxtail pie.
Tender shredded oxtail sits on top of a chewy crust, creating a rich and unforgettable bite. It’s different from anything you’ll find at most slice shops. If you’re looking to experience Brooklyn’s evolving food scene, Cuts & Slices easily ranks among the best pizza in Brooklyn.
For more unique eats, consider booking the Brooklyn neighborhood eats walking food tour during your NYC trip!
Cuts & Slices
⭐ Rating: 4.6/5
🗒️ Price range: $6–$30
📍 Address: 93 Howard Ave, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Sweet chili oxtail slice
8. Ops Bushwick
Sourdough Margherita pizza | Photo Credit: Rene Strgar on Pexels
Ops in Bushwick gives you a completely different pizza experience. Instead of traditional dough, this restaurant uses sourdough, giving the crust a slightly tangy flavor.
The pies are airy, chewy, and perfectly charred from the wood-fired oven. Seasonal toppings like sweet potatoes, ramps, and peppers keep the menu exciting. The cozy candlelit dining room also makes Ops a great choice for a casual date night.
If you’re looking for the best brick oven pizza Brooklyn offers with a modern twist, Ops should definitely be on your list.
Ops Bushwick
⭐ Rating: 4.7/5
🗒️ Price range: $15–$28
📍 Address: 346 Himrod St, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Sourdough margherita
9. Omar’s Fine Cuisine
Chicken Tikka pizza | Photo Credit: Flickr
Brooklyn’s food scene is incredibly diverse, and Omar’s Fine Cuisine proves that pizza can cross cultural boundaries. This restaurant is best known for its Indian-inspired pizzas. One of the favorites is the chicken tikka pie, which combines creamy sauce, spices, and melted cheese.
Another great option is the tawa vegetable pizza, filled with bold masala flavors. It’s a fun twist on traditional pizza and perfect for adventurous eaters.
If you love trying new things, which includes meals, Omar’s has one of the most unique pizza experiences in Brooklyn.
Omar’s Fine Cuisine
⭐ Rating: 4.4/5
🗒️ Price range: $12–$25
📍 Address: 179 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY
🍕 What to try: Chicken tikka pizza
FAQs about best pizza in Brooklyn
Where should I start if I want to try Brooklyn pizza?
If it’s your first time exploring Brooklyn’s pizza scene, start with iconic spots like Di Fara Pizza, L’Industrie Pizzeria, or Juliana’s Pizza. These places are known for their quality ingredients and classic techniques. Each has a slightly different style, from coal-oven pies to thin New York slices. Visiting a few of them is the best way to experience the best pizza in Brooklyn.
What is the number one pizza in the world, NYC?
New York City is often considered the pizza capital of the world. Many experts say the city’s classic New York-style slice is the most iconic pizza globally. In Brooklyn specifically, spots like Di Fara and L’Industrie are often ranked among the best. Their focus on quality ingredients and traditional baking methods makes them stand out.
What are the top pizza spots in Brooklyn?
Some of the top pizza spots include Di Fara Pizza, L’Industrie Pizzeria, Juliana’s Pizza Brooklyn, Totonno’s, and L&B Spumoni Gardens. These restaurants represent different styles, from coal-oven pies to Sicilian squares. Together, they showcase why Brooklyn is famous for its pizza culture.
What is the best NY-style pizza in Brooklyn?
New York-style pizza usually features a thin, foldable crust with simple toppings. L’Industrie Pizzeria and Di Fara are often considered the best places to try this style in Brooklyn. Their slices are crispy, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. If you want an authentic NYC pizza experience, these two spots are excellent choices.
What are the best Sicilian pizza spots in Brooklyn?
Sicilian pizza is known for its thick, square crust and rich tomato sauce. L&B Spumoni Gardens is widely considered one of the best places to try it in Brooklyn. Their famous upside-down square slice has been loved by locals for generations. It’s a must-try for any pizza fan.
Slice into the best pizza in Brooklyn
Brooklyn’s pizza scene is full of legendary spots, creative slice shops, and neighborhood favorites. So grab a slice, explore the borough, and experience the best pizza in Brooklyn for yourself. Want to make the most of your trip? Join Brooklyn food tours on Klook and discover even more amazing local eats.
Your next unforgettable New York food adventure is waiting!
What is Klook?
Klook is a leading pan-regional experiences platform in Asia Pacific, purpose built to digitalize experiences and make them accessible to every traveler.
Our mission is to build the digital infrastructure for the global experience economy — empowering merchants to share their passions and travelers to discover the heartbeat of each destination. We operate a mobile-first, curated platform featuring diverse experiences across global destinations.
✨ Follow us for more deals and inspiration for your upcoming travels
