The Garden City Hotel

Las clasificaciones por estrellas se basan en la visión general de Klook sobre la información de la propiedad (como los servicios e instalaciones incluidos, etc.), y son solo de referencia.

After a previous experience that missed the mark, I have to give credit to The Garden City Hotel team for listening and making things right. Our return stay was exactly what we hoped for—smooth check-in, great service, a wonderful lunch on property, and we fully enjoyed the amenities including the gym and pool. A special thank you to Angelina and the team for showing true hospitality and making sure we had a great experience. Having grown up in the area, this hotel has always been a Long Island landmark, and we’re happy to say we’ll definitely be returning for future stays.

Friendliness, helpfulness, professionalism of all staff was outstanding. Highly recommended.

Everything was perfect. We had breakfast in bed after a long day before for our wedding. It was the perfect ending to our day. Wish we stayed longer.

Be careful when ordering room service. We ordered a sandwich and flatbread. We thought it was from the restaurant, but it was from the gift shop reheated flatbread, and a pre-made sandwich.

The staff was incredible, considerate, sweet, helpful, fantastic. I hope they are paid well. Because this place charges an outrageous amount of money for a hotel that is neither historical/interesting nor modern/luxurious. What was supposedly a beautiful, historic hotel was torn down in the '70s. This place was built in the 80's. Unfortunately, it shows. The bathrooms in the rooms have been updated, and the rooms are spacious, but expect a noisy air conditioner, a view of a parking lot and a $50 per-head breakfast buffet swarming with fruit flies. Seems like a lovely place to get married or attend a high school prom. But this place needs to rebrand/remodel/redecorate or rethink its pricing. One could argue it's a great location. But I've paid the same amount per-night to stay in a fairytale, picturesque "grandhotel" built in the 1600's on the shore of an alpine lake in Switzerland. Seems like the Garden City Hotel could use some more local competition.

Awesome Stay, great accommodations

We always enjoy staying at the Garden City Hotel and have been returning twice a year—every summer and winter—for many years. The hotel itself is beautiful, but what truly makes our stay special is the incredible staff. Everyone is warm, professional, and welcoming. The housekeeping team does a wonderful job, and the valet staff are always friendly, helpful, and attentive. They consistently make us feel at home, and we truly appreciate their hard work. The only disappointment during this stay was our family dinner at King’s Restaurant. Unfortunately, the quality of the food did not meet the high standards we have come to expect from the hotel. The dishes lacked the level of preparation and excellence that such a wonderful property deserves. We hope management will address this, as improving the restaurant experience would make the hotel truly exceptional. Overall, we love staying here and look forward to returning again soon.

It was a perfect stay. It’s a well maintained hotel and the service is top notch. The food was excellent.

Nice

Amazing staff and stay. Highly recommend.