Facilities & services
Non-smoking throughoutNo elevatorHousekeepingGardenMeeting facilitiesFront desk (limited service hours)Where to?
Check-in/out dates
Select your dates
Guests and rooms
2 adults, 1 room
Find more hotels in Christiansted
Club Comanche Hotel, St. Croix 
No 1 Strand StreetSee mapNZ$ 271.32per night
This is the cheapest price in 30 days, based on the rates on 16 Sep
Top reasons for booking
Great view
Most user reviews comment positively on the view from their room
Popular facilities
Free WiFi
Luggage storage
Exploring the area
Protestant Cay Beach, 400m, About 6 mins from hotel by foot28
Classic Room
Bed type arranged at check-in
19.0 m²
No pictures available yet
Superior Suite
2 beds
27.9 m²
17
Premium Suite
1 double bed or bigger
25.0 m²
City view
No pictures available yet
Classic Suite
1 double bed or bigger
19.5 m²
Earn KlookCash for this booking & save on the next one
Reviews
Read all reviews
3.1/5.0
Good
544 reviewsLocation
4.4
Services offered
3.6
Cleanliness
2.9
Atmosphere & facilities
2.8
All
4.5+
3.0+
Reviewed: 16 Jun 2026
5.0/5.0
FantasticStayed with friends · For friends and family
Lots of character, great staff and in the perfect location.
Reviewed: 27 May 2026
5.0/5.0
FantasticSolo stay
I'd like to say that my stay there at club Comanche was a very great experience I like the atmosphere I was there The issue the fact they had Wi-Fi and the person that you put me to my room and explain all about the hotel was very pleasant and insightful about anything that I needed and also helpful The room was clean it was a very huge bed slept very well everything was 110% to my liking and I would recommend this place to a friend or family anytime I am looking forward to staying there again in the near future it was great my experience there The view and everything was great unlike the old-fashionedness of it too especially for somebody like me that was single it was not noisy was not crowded it was nicer that's all I can say it was very nice I enjoyed every minute and every day that I spent there and I would definitely be looking forward to spending some time there again hopefully it will be a longest day and I'll have an even better experience Thank you very much I appreciate it everything.
Reviewed: 25 May 2026
5.0/5.0
Fantastic Buen servicio
Reviewed: 27 Apr 2026
4.0/5.0
GreatFor business
Muy bonito y buen trato, pero el aire no enfria mucho
Reviewed: 19 Apr 2026
5.0/5.0
FantasticSolo stay
Clean room. Large room. Nice old fashioned room.
Reviewed: 7 Apr 2026
1.0/5.0
Below average Horrible experience. Hotel does not answer their phones and thats the only way to check in. They do not have a traditional front desk. One phone number is disconnected. The others just ring. I was unable to check in and still have not received my refund.
Reviewed: 9 Mar 2026
5.0/5.0
FantasticStayed with partner
I’ve been going to St Croix for 12 years and need to advise that if you’re looking for a 5 star luxury hotel / resort; you’re on the wrong island; goto St Thomas. Hotels here are mainly historic / small, which keeps with the island. With that said I loved staying at this hotel. It’s 300 years old; very clean, in the heart of everything, just feet from the restaurants / shops / water. The manager is on site. Being historic, if you stay in the top floors you must walk the stairs. I stayed in a top floor room (3rd story) with a nice ocean view; (yes it took a minute to get hot water but what’s the rush, the water was hot and you’re in a 300 yo hotel). It’s decorated with a lot of historical items and there is a very relaxed covered bar!). This is a perfect hotel for couples who want to relax, come and go as you please. I will staying here the next time I come to St Croix!
Reviewed: 9 Mar 2026
5.0/5.0
FantasticStayed with partner
What an amazing experience with this absolutely charming hotel! From walkikg in to the moment we left we were treated with such warmth, friendliness, cleanliness and hospitality that I personally have experienced thus far. 10 Stars hands down. Jamey, the hotel manager is spectacular. She helped us with whatever we needed, offered the most positive and friendliness in a person that's now a rarity. What a wonderful hotel and we can't wait to return
The Comanche Hotel will be the only Hotel we will ever book in St. Croix. Amazingly clean and charming room, ocean view, right downtown so everything is in blocks walk. Amazing Pavillion whwre they have sip and paint open air available monthly. Beautiful and wonderful. I can't say enough how much we enjoyed this Hotel experience.
Reviewed: 9 Mar 2026
4.0/5.0
GreatStayed with partner
Location is perfect. Hotel definitely needs upgrades but overall for the price and location it was good.
Reviewed: 8 Mar 2026
3.0/5.0
GoodSolo stay
The room is clean though there are bees on the bathroom floor every time I step in there. I don’t know where they are coming from. Floors are squeaky but it’s understandable because it’s an old house. However there are parts of the floor that are lifting up when you walk, so you have to be careful. I made the manager aware of this concerns before I left and she said she’s going to get it fixed. The manager is very friendly and accommodating. Overall experience was ok. I would recommend this place for people that just need a place to rest their heads but not a place for R&R.
Overview
Exploring the area
Attractions
Protestant Cay Beach
Non-smoking throughoutNo elevatorHousekeepingGardenMeeting facilitiesFront desk (limited service hours)